Types of sugar

How to Sweeten without the Sugar

Max. D Gray
By Max. D Gray. Updated: October 7, 2024
How to Sweeten without the Sugar
Image: egosportcenter.com

Baking recipes tend to use medium and high amounts of sugar, which people suffering from diabetes can't use. So, is that to say they cannot make and eat these delicious desserts? Of course they can! You just need to know the equivalence of sugar and sweetener so you can replace it. If you are diabetic or if you would simply prefer to exchange an item for another to follow a healthier diet, this OneHowTo article explains how to replace sugar with sweetener.

You may also be interested in: How To Replace White Refined Sugar

Steps to follow:

1

Sugar and sweeteners both enhance the sweetness of your food, but there's a crucial distinction: sweeteners are much more concentrated. This means you'll require significantly less sweetener than sugar to achieve an equivalent level of sweetness.

The exact amount of sweetener needed to replace sugar depends on the specific type of sweetener you are using, as well as its potency compared to sugar. Always refer to the specific product's packaging or guidelines for the best results when substituting sweeteners for sugar in recipes.

How to Sweeten without the Sugar - Step 1
2

While the market offers a variety of artificial sweeteners like aspartame, cyclamate, and saccharin, only saccharin holds up well for baking due to its high-temperature tolerance.

Additionally, these sweeteners come in various forms like powder, liquid, or pills, each catering to different needs.

3

When substituting sugar with powdered sweeteners like sucralose or aspartame in recipes, it's important to note that these sweeteners are significantly sweeter than sugar by weight. For example, sucralose can be around 600 times sweeter than sugar, while aspartame is about 200 times sweeter.

To determine the amount of sweetener needed as a substitute, you generally use much less than the amount of sugar called for in the recipe. A common guideline is to use about 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon of powdered sweetener for each teaspoon of sugar. For instance, if a recipe requires 250 grams of sugar, and you are using sucralose (which is 600 times sweeter), you might only need around 0.42 grams of sucralose (250 grams divided by 600).

This ensures you achieve the desired level of sweetness without overpowering the dish. Always refer to specific product guidelines or use conversion charts provided by the sweetener manufacturer for precise substitutions.

4

The statement about the equivalence between sugar and sweetener tablets needs clarification and correction:

Sweetener tablets, such as those containing sucralose or aspartame, are indeed more concentrated than granulated sugar. However, the specific formula mentioned (dividing by 10 and then multiplying by 2) does not accurately reflect the conversion ratio for most sweetener tablets.

Here’s a more accurate explanation:

- **Sweetener Tablets**: Sweetener tablets are highly concentrated forms of artificial sweeteners. Typically, these tablets are much sweeter than sugar, often by hundreds of times. For instance, a single tablet of sucralose or aspartame can be equivalent to several teaspoons of sugar in sweetness.

- **Calculation**: To substitute sugar with sweetener tablets, you generally need to use significantly fewer tablets than the equivalent amount of sugar. The exact conversion ratio varies depending on the brand and type of sweetener. It’s important to consult the specific product guidelines or use conversion charts provided by the manufacturer.

For example, if a recipe calls for 250 grams of sugar and you are using sweetener tablets that are, let's say, 200 times sweeter than sugar, you would need far fewer tablets than the 50 suggested. Typically, you might only need a fraction of a tablet or a few tablets, depending on the brand and strength.

In practice, always follow the manufacturer's instructions for the most accurate substitution of sugar with sweetener tablets in your recipes.

5

The statement about equivalence between sugar and liquid sweetener needs some clarification and correction:

Liquid sweeteners, such as honey or agave nectar, have a different density and sweetness level compared to granulated sugar or powdered sweeteners. While they do have similar weights per unit volume as powdered sweeteners, converting them from grams to milliliters involves understanding their specific properties.

Here's a more accurate explanation:

- **Density and Conversion**: Liquid sweeteners like honey or agave nectar are denser than water, so their volume in milliliters does not directly correspond to their weight in grams. The conversion ratio between grams of sugar and milliliters of liquid sweetener varies depending on the specific type of sweetener.

- **General Guidance**: To estimate the volume of liquid sweetener needed as a substitute for sugar in a recipe, you might use a rough guideline such as dividing the grams of sugar by a conversion factor. However, this factor can vary significantly based on the thickness and sweetness of the liquid sweetener.

- **Example**: For instance, if a recipe calls for 250 grams of sugar and you are substituting it with a liquid sweetener with a conversion factor of 12.5, you would calculate 250 grams divided by 12.5, resulting in approximately 20 milliliters of the liquid sweetener. This calculation provides a rough estimate, but precise measurements should be based on the specific product's guidelines.

In practical terms, always refer to the specific product's packaging or manufacturer's guidelines for the most accurate conversion of sugar to liquid sweetener in recipes. Adjustments may be necessary based on the sweetness intensity and consistency of the particular liquid sweetener you are using.

If you want to read similar articles to How to Sweeten without the Sugar, we recommend you visit our Food & drink category.

Write a comment
What did you think of this article?
4 comments
Rating:
Robert
Hello, I am wanting to use Sweet-n-low in a Potato Candy that calls for 32oz of Confectioners' Sugar. I did the math using a calculator. The result came out as 3.2 (.32/.10=). This does not sound correct to me Please advise me as to the correct amount of Sweet-N-Low needed. Thank you in advance.
Rating:
Robert
Hello, my dad is diabetic, he uses insulin as needed. I make a potato candy called "Needham". This is a local candy in Maine. I would like for him to enjoy them. Only the recipe calls for Two (2) One-pound packages of Confectioners' Sugar. I am terrible with math. what am I looking at for replacing the sugar with sweetener? I did the math with a calculator; the result was 3.2oz. This does not sound correct to me. Please advise me as to correct measurement.
Rating:
Barry
The recipe calls 2/3 cup of sugar how much sweet and low do I use?
Neet
2/3 of caster sugar is 133g. (according to howmany.wiki and other websites i checked) so the sweetener required to replace it would be 13.3g by the articles calculations.
Rating:
GUIDO CANGELOSI
I find it shocking that people like you who are so well versed into healthy foods and give high standard advice, would condone aspartame in the face of controversy. Personally, I would be neutral on the subject.
Jane Bertin (oneHOWTO editor)
Aspartame has been found safe by major organizations, including the European Food Safety Authority. Of course, we also propose other options to fit all opinions.
Image: egosportcenter.com
1 of 2
How to Sweeten without the Sugar