What is the Difference Between Sugar and Sweeteners?

Sugar most often refers to sucrose, the white granular substance added to food and drinks for sweetness. However, it also encompasses other naturally occurring sugars found in fruits, vegetables, and dairy products, such as fructose and lactose.

Sugar is a natural sweetener derived from various sources, and there are more types than many people realize. Some common types include:

• Sucrose: common table sugar derived from sugar cane.
• Fructose: found in fruits.
• Maltose: found in wheat and wheat-based cereals.
• Lactose, Galactose, and Glucose: found in everyday foods like milk and vegetables.

Although sugar is natural and present in foods humans have always consumed, it is not inherently good for you. While sugar provides significant energy and calories, excessive consumption can lead to various health problems, including weight gain and metabolic issues.

The health impact of sugar can vary depending on its source and processing. Refined white sugar, for example, is primarily sucrose, a disaccharide. This processing removes most of the molasses, which contains some vitamins and minerals. Brown sugar, on the other hand, retains some of this molasses, leading to slight differences in flavor profile, mineral content, and overall nutritional value.

Ready to put your newfound knowledge of sweeteners to use? Explore our guide to creating delectable sugar-free treats.

There are various types of sweeteners used to add sweetness to food and beverages. Unlike table sugar, which provides calories, some sweeteners offer a sweet taste with little to no calories. Let's explore these categories:

• Artificial sweeteners: these are lab-created substances many times sweeter than sugar, with minimal to no calories. Examples include aspartame, sucralose, and saccharin.
  
  
• Sugar alcohols: these can be naturally occurring in fruits or synthetically produced. They have fewer calories than sugar but still provide some, and can cause a laxative effect in high doses. Some examples include sorbitol, xylitol, and erythritol.
  
  
• Natural sweeteners: derived from plants, these offer a low-calorie alternative to sugar. They provide sweetness with minimal calories. Examples include stevia, monk fruit extract, and allulose.

Beyond offering a low-calorie sweetening option, sweeteners have various practical applications in the food industry. They can:

• Extend the shelf life of products: sweeteners act as preservatives, helping to prevent spoilage in jams, jellies, and other processed foods.
  
  
• Aid in fermentation: certain sweeteners, like sugar, play a crucial role in the fermentation process used for baking bread, yogurt production, and other fermented food items.
  
  
• Sweeten dietetic products: in sugar-free foods and beverages designed for diabetics or those seeking to control sugar intake, sweeteners provide a desirable sweet taste without the associated calories.

While non-nutritive sweeteners are helpful for reducing calorie intake, they are not without controversy. The long-term effects of excessive consumption of artificial sweeteners are still debated, and some synthetic sweeteners are surrounded by health concerns.

Now that you know the difference between sugar and sweeteners, learn how to effectively incorporate them into your diet.

Sugar and sweeteners are both used to add sweetness to food and drinks, but their properties differ significantly. Let's delve into the key areas that distinguish them:

Source:

• Sugar: comes from natural sources such as sugar cane, sugar beets, fruits, and dairy products.
  
  
• Sweeteners: can be either chemically manufactured or naturally derived. Some sweeteners, like aspartame and sucralose, are synthetic, while others, like stevia and monk fruit extract, are natural.

Caloric content:

• Sugar: provides energy and calories, with about 4 calories per gram. It adds sweetness and energy to foods and beverages.
  
  
• Sweeteners: typically provide little to no calories. For example, artificial sweeteners like aspartame and sucralose have negligible calories, while sugar alcohols have fewer calories than sugar but still some energy.

Absorption and energy:

• Sugar: absorbed quickly by the body, providing a rapid source of energy.
  
  
• Sweeteners: absorption rates vary. Artificial sweeteners are not metabolized for energy and have negligible effects on blood sugar. Sugar alcohols are absorbed more slowly and may provide some energy but generally less than sugar.

Health implications:

• Sugar: excessive consumption is associated with health issues such as obesity, type 2 diabetes, and high blood pressure.
  
  
• Sweeteners: used as sugar substitutes, especially for those with dietary restrictions or diabetes. However, overconsumption of certain sweeteners, particularly sugar alcohols, can lead to gastrointestinal issues such as diarrhea and stomach upset.

While sugar provides both sweetness and energy, sweeteners are designed to offer sweetness with minimal to no calories. It is important to note that both have their own health considerations and potential side effects.

Now that you know the difference between sugar and sweeteners, learn how to navigate food labels to identify hidden sugars in your favorite products.

Replacing sugar with sweeteners in your diet can be a practical way to reduce calorie intake and manage blood sugar levels.

First, consider the intensity of the sweetener you're using compared to sugar. Artificial sweeteners can be many times sweeter, so you'll need much less to achieve the desired sweetness level.

Different sweeteners have distinct tastes. Stevia, for example, can have a slightly bitter aftertaste, while sucralose might taste closer to sugar. Experiment to find one you enjoy.

Tips for replacing sugar with sweetener:

• Read the label: check the sweetness ratio of the chosen sweetener compared to sugar. This information is usually on the packaging.
  
  
• Start small: begin by using a smaller amount of sweetener than you would sugar and taste as you go. You can always add more, but subtracting is trickier.
  
  
• Baking considerations: some sweeteners can affect baking results. Artificial sweeteners might not bulk up baked goods like sugar, requiring recipe adjustments. Sugar alcohols can sometimes act as humectants (retain moisture), potentially altering texture. Research substitution recommendations for specific sweeteners when baking.

Keep in mind that while sweeteners can help reduce sugar intake, they shouldn't be a reason to overindulge in sugary treats.

If you want to read similar articles to What is the Difference Between Sugar and Sweeteners?, we recommend you visit our Food & drink category.